 |
“Bla-ma Mkhas-pa Bi-ji-ba” after a manuscript of the Yellow Edged Volume.
Likely meant as an icon of Tsan Bashilaha, or at least a member of his medical lineage. |
A few of our regular readers might think we are getting too ensconced in obscure corners of the universe of possible knowables. I’m not sure I can change their minds, although I ought to apologize. Every blog has a strong connection with what’s going on in my own life or in the world, even if it may not be so evident every time. What I can do is say right away what this blog is going to be about so you can decide if you want to go further into it or not. I am aware doing this is in clear violation of the rule to give evidence first before coming to conclusions. Anyway, this is where we’re going with or without you:
There are basically two lists of foreign physicians who had input into Tibetan medicine during the time of the empire: List A as I call it, comes from the first non-Yuthok-lineage Tibetan medical history, the one by Cherjé dating to 1206 (or 1266). Some time ago I noticed that this list contrasted markedly with another list in the Elder Yuthok biography (seemingly composed in the 17th century) that I will call List B, so I tended toward the conclusion that List A was much older and probably a lot more authentic. I’m made to reassess this position, since a newly emerging old medical history by a Zhijé school follower named Nyedowa, dating to somewhere around 1300, has List B, while a medical history by Drangti that I now estimate to date from around 1375 contains a variant of the same. Looking into this triad of 13th-14th-century histories, we can say that none of them were aware of an Imperial Period Yuthok, and that none of them mention the name of Galen (or Ga-le-nos, confirming something Yoeli-Tlalim said several years ago).* If you find anything interesting in that, read on, but if you don’t, go ahead and stop reading whenever you like.
(*In general I’m now inclined to say that Galenos usurped the place of Tsan Pashilaha as initiator of Greek medicine in Tibet, pushing him up by a century, and this would explain how their biographies are confounded, as if the story is the important thing, not the person it belongs to. I’m beginning to see some sense in this confusing set of signals. Each one of the three medical texts knows a little bit about the [12th-century] Yuthok by the name G.yu-thog Mgon-po, which is interesting, since they don’t even seem to know the longer name G.yu-thog-pa Yon-tan-mgon-po. In this blog I ignore the small medical histories from the decades surrounding 1200 composed by Yuthok and his disciple Yeshezung, although it is important to us to know that they are there, and they are the earliest Tibetan medical histories in existence to the best of my knowledge. The chronological order of medicine histories is: Yuthok > Yeshezung > Cherjé > Nyedowa > Drangti.)
It may seem, too, judging from some of this year’s blogs, that Tibeto-logic has turned in the direction of medical history. I assure you it’s only temporary. True, I’ve had an on-again off-again interest in Tibetan medicine since back in the 70’s. I wouldn’t say I know much yet. I’m not ready to hang up a shingle or perform diagnostic procedures or anything at all that practical. My first and only real teacher in that area of study, a traditional doctor from Mongolia sometimes known as “Louis Lama” after the street he lived on, was mainly famous for attending on Yul Brenner.
But enough with the name dropping already, I just wanted to say that my main motives have been to understand medical texts, not just because they are interesting — and of course they are — but because their vocabulary is often very important to know and recognize in other genres of Tibetan literature. I know it may come as a shock to some, but Tibetan medicine is my main reason for being interested in the subject of medicine at all. It’s practically true that whatever modern cosmopolitan medicine I have studied (beyond basic high-school biology and an early interest in herbal remedies) I’ve studied because I wanted to understand Tibetan medical texts better.
I’ve always been on the lookout for newly appearing old history books, too. And my readers who are as rare as they are dear to me are all well aware of my fascination for Padampa and his Zhijé tradition. So if I stop to count them up, I have a lot of reasons to get inordinately worked up about the book I’ll tell you about soon.
It happens from time to time that a previously unknown Tibetan history blindsides us by slipping into published form before we even knew it could possibly exist. In the present case, it’s something buried in a huge collection of facsimiles of mostly cursive manuscripts, so the chances of it being noticed are still very slim, all the more reason to write about it right away.
I’ll have more to say about the newly revealed medical history written by a lineage holder of the Zhijé School in a minute. But first let’s look at the rather well-known idea that there were foreign doctors who were influential in early days in Tibet, either through their medical writings or by their physical presence. Modern practitioners often present as established fact that there was a major medical conference in imperial times, a subject I won’t go into now although I see reasons to find this certainty amusing in its naiveté. (Please show me one source even close to being contemporary to the event and then we can start talking about it.) It isn’t always easy or even possible to decide whether a given foreign physician actually came to Tibet or just his writings, or just knowledge of his writings, but as time goes on we ought to keep trying to find out who they were and where they stayed if we can.
In a recent blog, I went a little bit into the issue of how the Four Tantras — regarded by nearly everyone as the single-most authoritative medical source for Tibetan practitioners of medicine — was created, largely on the basis of earlier writings, by the one and only Yuthok Yönten Gönpo somewhere near the last decades of the 12th century. Often overlooked in the discussion is a small piece of internal evidence found near the end of the fourth and last Tantra, in its next-to-last chapter. This passage confesses in a surprisingly direct way that a lot of materials from all over the known world went into its making. Yangga quotes it in his dissertation, at p. 262:
Through their manifestations, the Tathagatas taught, for the welfare
of all sentient beings, medical compounds
in India, moxibustion and vessel cleansing
therapy in China, primarily venesection in the Dolpo area, pulse and urine diagnosis in Tibet, “The Hundred Thousand [Teachings on] Medicine” to the circle
of gods, the eight sections of Caraka to the circle
of sages, the “Black Treatise of Mahadeva” to the circle
of non-Buddhists, and the “Cycle of Teachings on the Lords of the Three Families” to the circle of Buddhists. All of these medical traditions
are collected and presented in this treatise.
There is not another medical
tradition which has not been
included in this treatise.860
The official bilingual edition of the same passage (Subsequent Tantra, p. 295), reads like this, including the introductory sentence Yangga left off:
Then again Sage Yidlay Kye made this request, “O Great Sage Rigpa'i Yeshi, are there any medical practices which are not included in this Tantra?” To this request, he replied, “For the sake of all sentient beings, the Medicine Buddha, in his different emanations, taught the compounding of medicines in India, moxibustion and Channel cleansing therapy in China, venesection therapy, mainly in Dholpo and diagnosis through pulse and urine in Tibet. He gave a discourse on the Vase of Medical Practice to the retinue of Gods, the eight sections of Charaka Samhita to the retinue of Sages, the Tantra of Black Shiva to the retinue of Non-Buddhists while giving the ‘Lord of the three families’ to the Buddhist retinue. Everything is explained in a concise form in this Medical Tantra. There is no medical practice that is not included in this Tantra.
By the way, this version of the text with English translation published by the Men-Tsee-Khang in Dharamsala H.P. says on its very title page that it is “by Yuthok Yonten Gonpo,” but without specifying whether it was an elder or younger Yuthok. You have to read quite deeply into the front matter to figure out if there was a preference for one over the other. Anyway, one very interesting thing about this outline of various sources integrated into the Four Tantras is the mention of Dolpo district, now in northern Nepal. It may seem odd that such a small and perhaps to most people not-so significant place would have its contributions placed on the same level as India and China. Still, this fits with what we can know from some of our earliest listings of foreign doctors that we will get to momentarily. Dolpo doctors are credited with the medical technique of venesection (gtar-ga), which just means therapeutic bleeding. Another fancy word for it is phlebotomy. You might imagine this means using leeches, but you would be wrong. Yangga (p. 257) says their use was unknown to Tibetan medicine.*
(*For yet another English translation , see Gavin Kilty’s in Desi’s history, p. 86.)
A few comments on this passage: “Channel cleansing” must be a way of speaking about acupuncture based on how it is supposed to work, by making the Chi flow through the correct channels. Apart from the famous golden needle therapy, acupuncture isn’t much on display in Tibetan medicine, although moxibustion is well known there. The Tibetan word is me-btsa', and it means not only the practice but perhaps primarily the points on the body where the moxa ought to be applied. And me-btsa' is also used in geomancy for points on the earth that are regarded as crucial (as in earth moxa point, or sa'i me-btsa'). I think me-btsa' literally means fire tending, but it also seems to me it could be one of those Tibetanizing borrowings of a foreign word. I just haven't been able to puzzle this one out. The word moxa in moxabustion is supposed to come from a Japanese word for mugwort since in practice mugwort was often used for tinder. Moxibustion appears to be a compound half Japanese and half Greek. How many of those can you think of?
It is when we reach the Tibetan contribution to Tibetan medicine that hesitations enter in. What I mean is that for us today nothing could be clearer than that Tibetan medicine received its pulse diagnosis, a significant part of it at least, from China (proven among other things by the borrowing of Chinese terminology in the Four Tantras) and its urine diagnosis from Greek, Byzantine or early Islamic sources via the Somaradza.*
(*We went into this already in January of this year in this blog. Medicine in the Islamic world was largely inspired by and filled with Greek medicine as preserved through the Byzantine Era, primarily of Hippocratic & Galenic varieties, although we ought to mention "prophet medicine" as well [and I know there were indeed some early influences from the translation of Sanskrit medical sources], not to mention regional influences. The world of Islamic medicine in India is simply called 'Greek' or Unani medicine. The name Unani is, just like Sanskrit Yavana, ultimately from the place name Ionia in Greece. The Yu-na and Yo-na forms of the same are also known in early Tibetan geographical sources.)
So, even if we may have some problems with it, we cannot deny that, given our idea that these words were composed by Yutok in the late 12th century, this would be a remarkably early Tibetan source for a listing of the foreign sources integrated into Tibetan medicine.* But unlike the source we will put on display shortly, it doesn’t name any doctors, and the names of the foreign physicians are particularly fascinating to me. I suppose the fascination largely stems from a desire to puzzle out who they were, and I hope my readers are ready and willing to help out in this quest.
(*Of course there are still problems that require investigation that could change our minds. One is that Jangdag (Byang-bdag) the 15th-century initiator of the Jang System, one of the major schools of Tibetan medicine, excludes the last two chapters of the Later Tantra from his commentary on the Later Tantra and gives them one separate commentary of their own, numbering the chapters Chapter One and Chapter Two. Clearly Jangdag did not believe they properly belonged to the main body of the Later Tantra, and I suggest something or another should be made out of this fact.)
Although there are other non-Tibetan-language sources we might mention, there are by now three articles that focus on the lists of foreign physicians: one by F. Garrett and two others by D. Martin. The suggestions Martin made about possible identities of the foreign physicians have been found to be both plausible and ludicrous — in the views of different reviewers, naturally. I’m sure plausible was what he was aiming for. Of course speculation is usually regarded as a bad thing among seasoned academics, but there are times when clutching at straws is the best we can do given the nature of the evidence available. Nevertheless, formulating alternative hypotheses that may conceivably find support or fall flat is quite valid, and sometimes it's hard to know the difference between speculation and hypothesis forming, if there in fact is one. In this case, the foreign Byzantine (Phrom ~ From ~ Rome, i.e. Byzantium) physician’s name is parsed as Tsan Pashilaha, ignoring the phantom Sanskritism shi-la that tends to grab and pull people's attention in the wrong direction. But why, I wonder! If he is a foreign doctor from somewhere other than Indic culture, a piece of Sanskrit is probably the last thing we ought to expect. The Tsan is plausibly explained as a clan name, perhaps the Tzan clan of the Trebizond region, while the Pashilaha is imagined to conceal the common Byzantine name shared among commoners, doctors and kings (as also a title for kings in general) Basil[eos].
For the time being my main goal is not to argue for one or another identity so much as to add an important early testimony, a previously unknown medical history by a Zhijé scholar and lineage holder named Nyedowa (སྙེ་མདོ་བ་ཀུན་དགའ་དོན་གྲུབ། 1268-1328). His grandfather Tsondrü Sengge was the youngest of the Rog brothers. All three Rog brothers were disciples of the main holder of the Later Transmission lineage named Tenné. Tsondrü Sengge, who became the first chair of Nyedo in 1207, had three sons. The eldest son, Sönam Pel, was installed at Nyedo in 1229. Our author Nyedowa (as we’ll go on to call him) was the youngest of the three sons of Sönam Pel, becoming head of Nyedo in around 1316 following the death of his predecessor and oldest brother Nyedo Kunga Zangpo. These generations of the heads of Nyedo were as a group in interesting connections with the Drikung and Karma Kagyü schools as well as Kâlacakra lineages, so we may assume that their line of Zhijé transmission was absorbed into one of them as their lineage appears to disappear in the 7th generation following Padampa. Other Later Transmission lineages would continue right up until the time of Tsongkhapa and beyond. We know that both the first and second Dalai Lamas had close family connections with Zhijé followers.
The same Nyedowa that concerns us today was already known as an author of two different writings that can be categorized as histories. The first is the appendix he added to the 1277 version of the history of the Later Transmission of Zhijé that was composed by his older brother, in order to bring it up to date. This is available. The other is his history of the Kālacakra Tantra's transmission entitled Clusters of Precious Substances: The Emergence of the Glorious Kālacakra, that is known by title but still as far as I know unavailable.
The medical history has a simple title that may be simply translated, The Origins of Medical
Science together with its History. Based on its content we should add that this history is very much about Tibet’s medical history and not so interested as some others are in Indian medicine. I would have never known that this history existed and I would’ve never had the idea to procure a copy of it without the help of William McGrath. It has been published in the form of a facsimile of a cursive manuscript, so it isn’t particularly easy for many Tibetanists to read. For this reason I will type out the relevant part in Wylie transcription and relay what it says there in a rather hasty translation attempt. Sometimes in spots where the present manuscript is too obscure I had to rely on close parallels found in the medical history by Zur-mkhar-ba, who clearly copied large parts from Nyedowa.
First the passage on medicine during the early 7th-century reign of Songtsen Gampo:
de nas gdung rabs lnga na / spyan ras gzigs kyi sprul srong
btsan sgam pos dam pa chos kyi srol stod [gtod] pa ltar / gso rig gi'ang [.7]
srol btod / rgyal po sku snyung pa de dus bod nang sman pa med pas / rje blon
rnams kyis bka' bgros nas / 'thon mi sam bho †a / glang khams pa go cha na
gnyis la rje'i phyags (?) gser gyi pa tra 'dzub gang pa [.8] bdun dang / gser
phye bre do skur nas phyog nas sman pa rgya gar nas dharma râ dza dang / phrom
nas phrom rgyal mu rje the phrom yi sras rgyal po btsan pa shi la ha
dang / gsum gdan drang nas byon pa ra sa [2r] 'phrul snang du bzhugs su bcug /
Then, five generations after Lha Totori, the emanation of Avalokiteshvara by the name of Songtsen Gampo opened the way of the Holy Dharma. As he was doing so he also opened the way for medical science. In those days when the king got sick there were no physicians inside Tibet, so the lords and ministers held a meeting and sent off Thonmi Sambhota and Lang Khampa Gocha with seven royal golden certificates filled with their thumbprints and a couple of ounces of gold powder. From the foreign lands they invited three physicians. From India, Dharmarâja; from Byzantium, the Byzantine king Mu-rje The-phrom's son King Btsan Pa-shi-la-ha, and thirdly and lastly xxxx. When they arrived they were given places to stay in Rasa Trulnang Temple.*
(*There is an obvious omission of one doctor here, very likely the name of the Chinese doctor. Rasa Trulnang Temple means the one today best known as the Jokhang. One database lists 168 persons with name Basil in the centuries it covers (641-867), making it one of the most common names. I was thinking The-phrom could be Theophron, a possible Greek personal name, but Theophron couldn’t be found there.)
rje'i sku la gso ba'i dpyad dang sman mdzad pas snyun dngos
(dang gso?) / de nas rgyal pos gser phye bre lnga gzhal ba dang / phyi
rabs (phyin nas?) bzang po la za 'og gi stan dang / seng ldeng gi sga dang / gser g.yu'i srab
kyis [.2] brgyan pa phul te / bzhugs par zhus pas rgya gar nag gi sman pa ni
bzhugs par ma gnang mod kyi 'on kyang sman dpyad kyi srol gtod pa ni / dharma
râ dzas rlung mkhris bad kan gsum du phye nas de'i gnyen po sman gyis 'bu shag
che chung logs pa [~la sogs pa] sgyur ro // [.3]
Then [they] performed therapeutic procedures on the emperor's body and prepared medicines, so that the illness was cured. Then the king weighed out five ounces of gold and went to them. As a boon, he presented them with silk cushions, saddles of acacia wood, harnesses adorned with gold and turquoise. When he requesting them to stay on, the Indian and Chinese physicians declined the invitation, so the medical treatments they passed on were as follows: Dharmarâja translated works including the longer and shorter versions of the 'Bu-shag* after separating wind, bile and phlegm humours, making medicines as their remedies.
(*The 'Bu-shag text Kongtrul, p. 414, attributes to the time of Songtsen Gampo.)
ha shang ma hâ kyin dhas spyi gtsug nas rkang thil pa na
chad kyi dgos bcos kyi dpyad thor bu ba mang du sgyur nas gshegs so //
The Hoshang Mahakyindha translated several miscellaneous treatments for needed repairs of illnesses and breakages from the soles of the feet to the top of the head.
btsan pa shi la has / ja log gi dpyad gsum dang / rma bya ne
tsho de po gsum gyis gsungs pa'i sku gsum gyi skor log pa [~la sogs pa] sgyur zhing [.4]
bla'i sman par bzhugs shing khab bzhes / de la sras gsum byung pa ni che shos
gtsang du btang pa la / la stod byang gi bi ji'i rgyud pa snyes (snyems?) byung
ngo //
Tsan Pashilaha translated works including the cycles of the three bodies that speak of the three: peacock, parrot and rooster, and the three counterintuitive (ja-log, =gya-log) treatments. Then he stayed on as the High Physician (bla'i sman-pa) and took a wife. They had three sons, the eldest of whom was sent to Tsang Province, where he was forebearer of the lineage of Biji in Latö Jang.
'bring po g.yor por stang ste g.yor po sa gtsub pas mgo la
mkhas dgos gsungs nas / na ga [.5] ra dza'i mda' bcos / na ran dza na'i gzer
bdus / mda' bcos le'u bzhi pa / rtsa ba rin po 'phrul gyi bzhi skor skor /
'grel dmyal khrag 'jag che chung gnyis / mgo dpyad la bzhi / bu dgu / lha ba'i
mgo 'dren che chung / za hor [.6] rgyal po'i lag gnon / rtsa bcos pa'i man ngag
bsdus pa / srog gi 'khor lo che chung gnyis / mda' bcos klad pa bcos pa dang
bcas pa bskur ro [~bsgyur ro] // de las lho stong kha'i sman pa rnams byung go //
The middle son was sent to Yorpo. The ground of Yorpo was rough,* so they said they needed a wise man for their head. Then he translated [a long list of texts, with texts on arrow wounds and head injuries prominent among them]. From him emerged the physicians of southern Tongkha.
(*Note: Based on parallels I think this ought to be saying, "Since Yorpo was a rough land [the Emperor] said they needed someone skilled in treating head injuries." I imagine this is about the roughness of the local people and not the landscape.)
chung shos dbu rur [.7] bzhag ste dbu ru mi ngan pas 'khrug
pa mod (yod?) pas yan lag dang byang khog nang ste / de po'i (?) sku bstod smad
kyis gsang brtsal ba / ne tsho'i sku stod kyi lus la kha mar gdags pa / rma
bya'i sku [2v] stod smad kyis chings dang chas kyi rin 'od gsal ba la / gnas
lugs gzhi la mkhas pas rgol ba tshar gcod pa / bla ma rgyud pa'i gdams pa /
theg pa so so la mkhas pa dris pa [2.] nges shes bskyed pa / shri rab can gyi
gdams pa / gdams ngag gi gal mig (bdal yig?) la mkhas pas rmongs pa'i 'khrul
bzhi sel ba / lag len dmar khrid kyi gdams pa drug pa phrom gyi dbye ba drug pa
[.3] ces bya ba bte (btod?) / de logs pa [~la sogs pa] byang khog dang yan lag gi dmigs /
rtsa dang / tshigs dang / rus pa dang / gsun dang rgyus pa dang / rnag dang chu
ser gyi gnad bcos thabs mang po dang / byang khog la stod rin po che gser gyi
sgrum bu / smad rin po che lcag [.4] kyi sgrum bu / log non rin po che bang
mdzod kyi sgrum bu / ro khra phying (khrad bying?) khrel 'phrul gyi me long la
'grel pa brgyad / gnad kyi yi ge gsum / mi 'gyur ba'i btag pa gnyis / ma lnga
bu lnga'i gdams pa'i // de lhas par bzhugs pa'i rgyud pa la sog po [.5] sman pa zhes
grags so // dus ding sang ni rabs chad nas med do // sman rgyud 'dzin pa 'di gnya' dang mtha' bzhi logs pa'o [~la sogs pa'o] //
The youngest son stayed in the Central Horn where bad men were feuding so the Emperor said they needed a specialist in injuries of the limbs and torso ... [That only made sense in the parallel text, not here... I won’t translate the rest of this bit yet. It is mostly titles of the works he translated, primarily on wound-associated topics] ... Those who remained in Lhepa formed a lineage that became known as Sogpo Doctors. Nowadays this ancestral lineage has come to an end and no longer exists. But the holders of the medical lineage include today’s Gnya' and Mtha'-bzhi among others.*
(*Zur-mkhar-ba in his medical history thinks it a contradiction to say these other medical lineages from the imperial period are continuing this one, but I just read our text as saying that in so far as the medical teachings of the Biji lineage still survived at the time of writing, they survived within these two other schools. The Biji lineage proper was already history, yet some of its practices continued.)
•
Now the Nyedowa history moves on to the time of Trisongdetsen, basically covering the 2nd half of the 8th century. Although this is the part that is of most interest, it is also longer and more involved. We won’t translate it here, but focus on the list of foreign physicians who visited Tibet during his time. Tibetan-language readers who don’t despise Wylie will be able to read it all in the link I’ll supply later on. All I would like to do for the remainder of this blog is to lay out the early evidence for two distinct lists of foreign physicians, both going back at least as far as the 13th century. Indic names are wherever possible turned into fine Sanskrit names with diacritic marks and everything. As part of my dream that some historian of Eurasian medicine will recognize some of the non-Indic names, I’ve supplied them also in phonetic versions. Please, if something strikes you as a possibility, share your idea in the comment section so we can seriously contemplate it together.
§ § §
Two Different Lists of
Foreign Doctors
Source for List A —
This
is the list of foreign physicians as found in the 1204 (or possibly 1264)
history by Cherjé, based on the Tucci manuscript kept in Rome. The heading that describes them appears as: mkhas-ldan mnga' rig[s]-gi lugs (School
of the ‘Scholarly Powerful Families’ [?], but they are later referred to as lnga rig-pa'i mkhas-pa, ‘Scholars of
the Five Sciences’), which is so much more likely to be correct. Chinese and Tibetan medicines each is given a separate
category of its own, which explains why they are lacking in this particular
context. Here I put up, next to Cherjé’s,
the comparable list of ten different national [non-Tibetan] medical systems in
Drangti’s history (unlike Cherjé’s it includes Chinese medicine in its list).
For the Drangti list, originally courtesy of Kurtis Schaeffer, I’ve compared
the partial manuscript with the 2005 publication, pp. 70-71, and noted the differences. Neither the Cherjé nor the Brangti supplies any specific time frame for the authors it mentions here, but Brangti later on gives a version of List B as well (placing its doctors in the time of Trisongdetsen):
Cherjé’s
history:
|
Drangti’s
history (perhaps ca. 1375): Ten different national [non-Tibetan] medical
systems:
|
[1a]
Slob-dpon Dpa'-bo [Ācārya Śūra, here meaning Vāgbhaṭa] composed four texts
(titles listed).
|
[1] Slob-dpon
Dpa'-bo [Ācārya Śūra, here meaning Vāgbhaṭa] composed Yan-lag Brgyad-pa'i Snying-po Bsdus-pa
etc. Western Kashmir (Kha-che
Nub-phyogs) System.
|
[1b]
Brtan-pa'i-blo-gros [Sthiramati] composed Dri-ma
Med-pa'i [xxx], etc. Kashmiri (Kha-che) System.
|
[2] Brtan-pa-blo-gros
[Sthiramati] composed Dri-med
Gzi-brjid etc. Eastern
Kashmir (Kha-che Shar-phyogs) System.
|
[2] Dzi-na-mi-tra [Jinamitra] composed Gso-ba Stong-dgu-bcu-rtsa-gcig [‘A
Thousand Ninety-One Healing Methods’], etc. Orgyan (U-rgyan) System.
|
[3]
Dzi-na-mi-tra [Jinamitra] composed Gso[-ba]
Stong-dgu-brgya-rtsa-bzhi-pa etc. Urgyan (Dbu-rgyan) System.
|
[3] Pra-a-nan-ta [Śrī Ānanda in Sde-srid’s
history] composed Gnas-'gyur Gsum [Three Transformations in the Situation],
etc. Magadha (Dbus-'gyur-'chang) System.
|
[4]
Tra-a-nan-ta [?] composed Gnas-'gyur
Gsum[-pa] etc. Nepal Valley (Bal-po) System. [Note: the 2005
publication, p. 71, has Shrî A-nan-ta.]
|
[4] Su-ma-ti-kirti [Sumatikīrti] composed Bsdus-sbyor Gsum [Three Abbreviated Preparations], etc. Newar (Bal-po) System.
|
|
[5]
Ur-pa-ya [?] composed Chos-'byung
Drug [Six Origins of Things],
etc. Arabo-Persian (Stag-gzig) System.
|
[5]
Ur-ba-ya [?] composed Chos-'byung Drug
etc. Arabo-Persian (Stag-gzig) System.
[fol. 26b] (Note: The 2005 reads Ud-pa-la.)
|
[6] Rdo-rje-'bar-ba composed Mi-'jigs-pa'i Mtshon-cha Che Chung [Greater and Lesser Weapons of Fearlessness],
etc. Dolpo (Dol-po) System.
|
[6]
Rdo-rje-'bar-ba composed Mi-'jigs Mtshon-cha etc. Dolpo (Dol-bu/Dol-po) System.
|
[7] Legs-pa'i-rgyan composed Ga-gon-gyi rdol-thabs Su[m]-bcu-rtsa-lnga
[Thirty five Methods for Spontaneous
Emergence of Ga-gon], etc. Uighur
(Hor) System.
|
[7]
Legs-pa'i-rgyan-gyi-blo-gros composed Ga-gon-gyi Dol-thabs
etc. Uighur (Hor) System.
|
|
Here the
2005 adds two national systems with anonymous authors: [a] Rgyud
Gsum-gyi Mdo-byang Che Chung etc.
Turk (Dru-gu) System [b] 'Dus-pa Rin-po-che'i Srog-'khor
etc. Sogdian (Sog-po) System.
|
[8]
Brtson-'grus-snying-po composed Sum-khugs,
etc. Tangut/Xixia (Me-nyag) System.
|
Only the
2005 edition has this: Brtson-'grus-snying-po
composed Gsum-khungs etc. Tangut (Mi-nyag) System.
|
[9]
Rgyal-ba'i-rdo-rje [Jinavajra or [Vi]jayavajra??] composed Yan[ lag] bdun pa [Seven Limbs], etc. Khotanese (Li) System.
|
[8]
Rgyal-ba-rdo-rje composed Yan-lag
Bdun-pa etc. Khotanese (Li) System.
|
[10] Btsan
Pa-shing-la-ha [Tsan Pa-shi-la-ha] composed the Tshad pa'i 'gros 'ded (‘Drawing
the Course of the Fever’), etc.
Phrom ('Brom, sic) System.
|
[9] Tsam
Pa-shi-la-ha composed Tshad-pa 'Bros
'Ded etc. Byzantine (Khrom)
System.
The 2005 has Tsan Pa-shi-la-ha, and [oddly] spells Khrom as Khroms.
|
|
[10]
Ha-shang Ma-ha-ya-na [Hoshang Mahoyen] composed [six text titles given in the
text] etc. Chinese [Rgya-nag)
System.
|
For a later source, yet one with some superior readings, see Gavin Kilty's translation of Desi's history, p. 169.
Sources for List B —
[B.1] Snye-mdo-ba's ca. 1300 medical history, fol. 3r. These
physicians were invited in reign of Trisongdetsen (Khri-srong-lde-brtsan):
[1] [From
India] a tsarya Shanting-garba.
[2] From
Kashmir (Kha-phye) Gu-ya-badzra.
[3-5] From
China (Rgya-nag) Stong-gsum-gang-ba, Bha-la-ha-shang, & Ha-ti-sa-ha.
[6] From
Tazik (Stag-gzig) Sog-po Ha-la-shan-tir.
Note: There are signs a bit of text was dropped here, and the name of
the Tazik (Arabo-Persian) physician is the very thing that must be missing
here.
[7] From the
Turks (Gru-gu) Se-mdo-'od-chen.
[8] The Dolpo
physician (Dol-po'i sman-pa [illeg. syllable]) Dharma-shi-la.
On
4r, Nyedowa lists them again, each with a list of their translations that would
be presented to the Emperor. Except the first, only their nationalities are
supplied in this context, not their proper names:
[1] slob dpon Shanting-garba.
The [Indian] Teacher Śāntigarbha.
— slob dpon shanting garbas bas shâkya thub pa mngos kyis sya
[~gsungs] pa'i bse sgrom dmar po dang / sangs rgyas sman lhas sya [~gsungs]
pa'i shlau ka sde bzhi dang / bdud rtsi [.4] lhung zer [~zed] che chung dang /
bdud rtsi dum snying dang / spyan ras gzigs gyis gsungs pa'i spungs pa sde lnga
dang / rdo rje 'chang gis mdzad pa'i tsa
ra ka'i grel pa dang / slob dpon klu sgrub kyis mdzad pa'i rtsa mdo' la sogs pa
rnams la 'gyur byas so //
[2] Rgya-nag-gi sman-pa.
The physician[s] of China. — rgya nag gi sman
pas / 'jam dpal gyi [.5] gsungs pa'i sbyor ba dang / byang khog don khrems /
yan lag gi mda' las byung pa / rin po che'i mdzod lnga la sogs pa dang me chu
go zlog dang / thor bu'i dpyad dang / chu dpyad / 'khrugs dpyad / me rtsa'i lag
len sgran me dang / dug dpyad me lce 'khor lo [.6] logs [~la sogs] pa rnams
sgyur ro //
[3] Kha-phye'i sman-pa.
The Kashmir physician. — kha phye'i sman
pas / sman gyi dpyad mdo dgu pa dang / spyad kyi phreng sel bar byed pa mun
pa'i sgrol me dang / man ngag gnad kyi phra thig dang / rdo rje 'chang zla
dga'i gzhu chung [~gzhung chung] mdor bsdus pa rnams sgyur ro //
[4] Sog-po'i sman-pa.
The Sogdian physician. — sog po'i sman pas
[.7] mgo mu rnyegs skor brgyad rtsa 'grel dang / rtsa bcos pa'i man ngag ljon
shing che chung gnyis / 'dus bcos thobs rin chen srog gi 'khor lo / sog po sha
thag bcan gyi rgyud / dug gso ba gar log rgyal po'i shi bsos bcog brdungs rnams
so // [4v]
[5] Dol-po'i sman-pa.
The Dolpo physician. — dol po'i sman pas
/ sangs rgyas sman lhas seng sdeng nags kyi sgrol me byin gyis rlabs te / sman
gyi lha mo brgya rtsa gnyis kyi bshad pa'i mi 'jigs pa brgyad kyi mtshon cha
dang / gab pa bsal byed dang / nad ngos 'dzin pa'i le'u lnga pa la rten nas
'tsho [.2] mchi rtya [~'chi rtags] kyi le'u dang / rtsa'i legs nye brtag pa
dang / gtar kha'i dpyad rnams sgyur ro //
[6] Gru-gu sman-pa. The
Turkic physician. — gru gu sman pas / phyag na rdo rjes
gsungs pa'i nag po rgyud gsum dang / de'i mdo byang che chung gnyis dang / 'dra
bar 'byed pa dung gi mig can dang / nags su 'jug pa g.yu'i [.3] dra ba can / gu
na sha tra bam po lnga brgyangs logs pa dang / rta'i dpyad rnams sgyur te / de
bzang dpyad dang ngan dpyad gnyis las / dang po la rta la khams lngar phye te /
'ol ba rlung gi khams / jag ro me / ro rgyu chu / mgo rtse pa / gyi ling nam
kha'i khams so // [.4] ngan spyad la rta'i nad / lhed la rgo g.yung
gnyis / lcam ma bu gnyis / bye gsar rnying gnyis / gyen bu dang thur bu gnyis /
gam pa la phyi gam pa brgyad / nang gam pa la brgyad / 'khrugs drod mo dang bcu
bdun / mtheng la drug bcu gcig tu phye
ba'o //
[7] Bal-pa'i sman-pa (i.e., Bal-po'i sman-pa, from Kathmandu
Valley). — bal pa'i sman pas [.5] 'phags pa byams
pas lha dang lha min rnams la gsungs pa / 'gram bam tig dang / sbyor ba brgya
pa dang / rin po che sman gyi ''khrung dpe dang / thur dpyad dang / lhog pa'i
gso thab rnams sgyur ro //
[B.2] Brang-ti Dpal-ldan-'tsho-byed, Bdud-rtsi Snying-po Yan-lag Brgyad-pa Gsang-ba Man-ngag-gi Rgyud-kyi
Spyi-don Shes-bya Rab-gsal, Smanrtsis Shesrig Spendzod series no. 148,
Tashi Y. Tashigang (Delhi 2005), p. 77. These physicians Drangti locates in the time of Trisongdetsen (last half of 8th century):
[1] Rgya-gar-gyi
sman-pa a-tsarya Shan-ti-garbha. / From India, the physician Ācārya Śāntigarbha.
[2]
Rgya-nag-nas Stong-gsum-gang-ba. / From China, Tongsumgangwa (Tibetan for
'Triple Thousand Universe Filled').
[3] - -
- Bha-ma-ha-shang. / [From China,] Bhama Hoshang.
[4] - -
- Ha-ri-pa-ta. / [From China,] Haripata [the name appears Indic, not Sinitic].
[5]
Stag-gzig-nas Sog-po Ha-la-shan-dhīr. / From Arabo-Persian lands, the Sogdian
Halashandhir.
[6]
Gru-gu-nas Seng-ge-'od-chen. / From Turkestan, Sengé Öchen.
[7]
Dol-po-nas Khyo-ma-ru-tse. / From Dolpo, Kyomarutse.
[8]
Bal-po'i sman-pa Dha-na-shi-la. / Physician
of the Nepal Valley Dhanashila (perhaps Dānaśīla
was intended?).
[B.3]
The nine physicians who came to Tibet at the invitation of Emperor Trisongdetsen according to Zur-mkhar-ba’s sixteenth-century medical
history (pp. 255-6), evidently based on the just-given passage of Drangti’s medical
history, yet not identical to it:
From India (Rgya-gar):
1. Shan-ti-garbha [Śāntigarbha].
From Kashmir (Kha-che):
2. Guhya-badzra [Guhyavajra].
From China (Rgya-nag):
3. Stong-gsum-gang-ba.
4. Bha-la Ha-shang.
5. Ha-ti-pra-ta.
From Tazig (Stag-gzig):
6. Sog-po Ha-la-shan-ti.
From "the Turks" (Dru-gu):
7. Seng-mdo-'od-chen.
From Dolpo (Dol-po):
8. Khyol-ma-ru-rtse.
From Nepal Valley (Bal-po):
9. Dharmā-shi-la [Dharmaśīla].
[B.4] The comparable passage in the biography of
the Elder G.yu-thog-pa attributed to Lhun-grub-bkra-shis (perhaps only written in the
17th century) is translated into English in Rechung Rinpoche Jampal Kunzang, Tibetan Medicine Illustrated in Original
Texts, University of California Press (Berkeley 1976), pp. 202-209. The
same text in the original Tibetan (based on the 1982 edition, pp. 100-101)
reads as follows, with the original Tibetan and an English translation side by
side. Notice how this source adds Tsan Pashilaha to the end of List B:
[1]
Rgya-gar Shantiṃ-garbha'i lugs la lus spyi gso ba'i yan lag bdud rtsi'i chu
rgyun.
|
Indian
Śāntigarbha. Associated text: The
Branch Covering the Healing of the Whole Body: Flowing Stream of Elixir.
|
[2]
Rgya-nag ni sman-pa Stong-gsum-gang-ba'i lugs la byis pa gso ba'i yan lag
chung dpyad nyi ma'i 'od zer.
|
Chinese
physician Stong-gsum-gang-ba. The Branch
Covering the Healing of Children: A Ray of Light for Treating the Small.
|
[3]
Ma-hā-de-wa'i lugs la mo nad gso ba'i yan lag zla ba'i dkyil 'khor.
|
[Chinese]
Mahādeva. The Branch Covering the
Healing of Women's Ailments: Circle of the Moon.
|
[4]
Dharma-buddha'i lugs la gdon nad gso ba'i yan lag rdo rje pha lam.
|
[Chinese]
Dharmabuddha (?). The Branch Covering
Dön Spirit Diseases: The Diamond.
|
[5]
Bal-po'i sman-pa Da-na-shī-la'i lugs la rgas pa gso ba'i yan lag gnad kyi
mdzub tshugs.
|
The
Nepal Valley physician Danaśīla. The Branch Covering Old Age Ailments:
Sticking the Thumb in the Vulnerable Spot.
|
[6]
Kha-che'i sman-pa Khun-badzra-gyi lugs la dug nad gso ba'i yan lag rus sbal
gyi 'gyur 'gros.
|
The
Kashmir physician Guṇavajra (?). The
Branch Covering Curing of Ailments from Poisons: The Changing Condition of
the Turtle.
|
[7]
Sog-po'i sman-pa Na-la-shan-dir-pa'i lugs la rgas pa gso ba'i yan lag bcud
kyi rgya mtsho.
|
The
Sogdian physician Nalashandirpa (?).
The Branch Covering Old Age Ailments: Ocean of Nutrition.
|
[8]
Dol-po'i sman-pa Khyo-ma-ru-rtse'i lugs la ro rtsa gso ba'i yan lag dga' bde
'phel byed.
|
The
Dolpo physician Khyomarutsé (?). The
Branch Covering the Treatment of Virility: Making Joy Increase.
|
[9]
Gru-gu'i sman-pa Seng-ge-'od-can-'phel-byed-kyi lugs la btsal ba thig gi yan
lag ro bkra 'phrul gyi me long.
|
The
Turkic physician Sengge-öchan-peljé (?).
The Branch Covering Lines of Vermillion (?): The Amazing Mirror of
Anatomical Charts.
|
[10]
Khrom-rgyal Mu-rtse The-khrom-gyi sras Btsan Pa-shi-la-hi'i lugs la khrom gyi
dbye ba drug pa la sogs pa yin no.
|
Tsan
Pashilahi, son of the Byzantine King Murtsé T'etröm (?). The Byzantine Six Divisions etc.*
|
*I’ve suggested before
the possibility that by Six Divisions,
the Galenic idea of the Six Non-naturals**
(sex
res non naturales, to give the Latin) could
be intended. These were factors of diet
and activity that require regulation to achieve a healthy balance in the body. In Galenic medicine they are regarded as potential causes or preventers of ailments. In general they cover the territory of what would in older times have been called hygiene, and nowadays preventative medicine. I know that "non-natural" sounds odd to everyone, but that only means that they are not body-intrinsic (not part of the body's natural constituents), but rather have to do with interactions between the body and the external world. I’ve speculated already about possible or plausible ways to explain the names
given here, on the assumption they are Byzantine Greek names. I invite you to
come with other ideas besides my own.
**There
are a number of important articles on this subject, so I hope to study them
before commenting further. An ordinary listing of the Six
Non-naturals follows: 1. air (climate), 2. exercise (and rest),
3. food (and drink), 4. sleep (and wakefulness), 5. elimination of wastes and
6. emotional states. There must be a reason for the 'six-ness' found in
the teachings of both Tsan Pashilaha of Byzantium and Urpaya of Arabo-Persian
lands. In both regions the Six Non-Naturals were widely known. But we need additional reasons to believe in this particular connection.
Posts
